As a landlord, it might seem obvious that once your tenant returns the keys, the tenancy must be over. But in UK law, it doesn’t work like that. A tenant returning keys to landlord before the end of a fixed-term tenancy does not automatically end the agreement.
In most cases, this is treated as an offer to surrender the tenancy. Whether the tenancy ends depends on your response and your actions.
Here’s what you need to know, including what happens if you re-let the property too soon
- Returning Keys to Landlord: Does It End the Tenancy?
- Tenant Returning Keys to Landlord Early – What It Means Legally
- Implied Surrender: How Returning Keys Affects the Tenancy
- Re-Letting After a Tenant Returns Keys: Risks & Legal Pitfalls
- What Should Landlords Do When a Tenant Returns Keys Early?
- Why Accepting Keys Early Matters for Landlords
Returning Keys to Landlord: Does It End the Tenancy?
A fixed-term tenancy is a binding contract, usually lasting for 6 or 12 months. If there is no break clause and the tenant leaves early, they are still legally responsible for the rent unless:
-
You agree to end the tenancy early
-
A new tenant moves in with your agreement
-
The break clause is used correctly
Tenant Returning Keys to Landlord Early – What It Means Legally
When a tenant returns the keys, this is legally treated as an offer to surrender the tenancy. It’s your decision whether to accept it.
You can:
-
Accept the surrender, either in writing or through your actions
-
Reject the surrender and confirm that the tenancy is still running
If you accept, the tenancy ends. If you reject it, the tenant remains responsible for the rent and all other obligations until the fixed term ends.
Implied Surrender: How Returning Keys Affects the Tenancy
This is where landlords can get caught out. Even if you don’t formally accept the surrender, a court may say that you accepted it through your actions. This is known as surrender by operation of law.
It happens when both landlord and tenant behave in a way that clearly shows the tenancy is over.
What Counts as Accepting the Keys? (Landlord Actions That Matter)
Common examples of implied surrender include:
-
Advertising the property for new tenants
-
Entering into a new tenancy
-
Changing the locks or taking back possession
-
Removing the tenant’s belongings
-
Carrying out non-urgent renovations
These actions suggest that you have taken back control of the property. At that point, it becomes very difficult to argue that the tenant still has legal responsibilities.
Re-Letting After a Tenant Returns Keys: Risks & Legal Pitfalls
One of the clearest signs of implied surrender is putting the property back on the market. If you list it online, arrange viewings, or accept holding deposits, this can be taken as a sign that you consider the previous tenancy over.
If the tenant has already handed back the keys, a court could easily say you accepted the surrender based on your actions.
What Should Landlords Do When a Tenant Returns Keys Early?
If a tenant hands back the keys early, here’s how to protect your position:
-
Decide whether you are accepting or rejecting the surrender.
-
If you reject it, write to the tenant stating that the tenancy is still running and they remain liable.
-
If you accept it, confirm in writing that the tenancy has ended.
-
Do not advertise or re-let the property until the first tenancy is clearly ended.
Why Accepting Keys Early Matters for Landlords
If you accept a surrender, the tenancy ends. That means:
-
You cannot claim rent after the surrender date.
-
You may lose access to legal remedies under the original tenancy.
-
You risk legal issues if you re-let too soon.
Clear communication and proper documentation are essential.
FAQs: Tenant Returning Keys Before Tenancy Ends
1. Is the tenancy over once the tenant gives me the keys?
No. It only ends if you accept the keys and treat the tenancy as ended.
2. What counts as ‘accepting’ the keys?
Accepting can be done verbally or through actions. If you take back control of the property, such as re-letting or redecorating, this can be treated as acceptance.
3. Can I re-let the property straight away?
Only if the tenancy has been clearly ended. If you re-let too soon, you risk creating overlapping tenancies.
4. Is the tenant still liable for rent?
Yes, unless you’ve accepted the surrender. They remain liable until the fixed term ends or a new tenant takes over.
5. Do I need something in writing?
Yes. A simple written confirmation protects you and avoids future disputes.
If you’re unsure, get advice before you take any steps that could be seen as accepting the surrender. It’s easy to lose your legal position by acting too quickly.
Mutual Surrender of Tenancy Agreement (Template)
Here’s a straightforward Surrender Agreement Template you can use when a tenant returns the keys and both parties agree to end the tenancy early. This is suitable for residential tenancies in England and Wales. You should adjust it if there are joint tenants or additional clauses involved.
Resources:
Surrender by operation of law – UK Government
